Tax gains made people who are taking an interest deduction on property investments.

Tax gains made people who are taking an interest deduction on property investments.

I don't agree that this policy is fair because it fails to take into account the impact of interest. The scenarios are faulty. A person who buys a $300,000 house is not getting a free benefit because they are paying interest which is often the equivalent of the rental they would be paying. On the other hand, a person who invests in a house and leases it earns rentals that offset the interest they pay. Effectively they therefore often pay no costs (rent = interest), no tax and get a tax free capital gain at the end. My suggestion would therefore be to require all people who want to take a deduction for interest on a residential property to register that property into a scheme (a bit like registering for GST) because they are obviously buying the property as a commercial venture. Any gains on the value of that property upon future transfer (including transfer out of the scheme) would be subject to tax. This scheme would automatically exempt those people who are buying their property for their family home and yes it would exempt the really rich who can buy a property and not rent it or live in it, but I don't think those purchases are behind the the significant increase in investment properties.

Showing 4 reactions

How would you tag this suggestion?

Sign in with

Or sign in with email

    Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
    • Tim O’Donnell
      commented 2016-12-10 11:27:17 +1300
      His idea also takes into account people with a mortgage (people paying interest) so your point is irrelevant
    • Tim O’Donnell
      commented 2016-12-10 11:23:29 +1300
      You don’t pay interest once you pay off your mortgage. You don’t have to be rich to have done this, just work hard, go without the luxuries others have & be generally smart with your money.
    • Tim O’Donnell
      tagged this with bad 2016-12-10 11:23:29 +1300
    • Joanne Clough
      published this page in How would you make New Zealand Fair Again? 2016-12-10 10:05:36 +1300