Candidates Auckland Central | Tuariki Delamere Banks Peninsula | Ben Atkinson Bay of Plenty | Chris Jenkins Coromandel | Rob Hunter Dunedin | Ben Peters Epsom | Adriana Christie Hamilton East | Naomi Pocock Hamilton West | Hayden Cargo Hutt South | Ben Wylie-van Eerd Mount Albert | Cameron Lord Nelson | Mathew Pottinger New Plymouth | Dan Thurston-Crow North Shore | Shai Navot Northland | Helen Jeremiah Ōhāriu | Jessica Hammond Rongotai | Geoff Simmons Southland | Joel Rowlands Tauranga | Andrew Caie Te Atatū | Brendon Monk Wellington Central | Abe Gray Whangārei | Ciara Swords
- Comms & Events
12. What is wrong with grandparenting? Shouldn’t nutrient allocations to farmers acknowledge past investments?
No, that would be to arbitrarily protect the most polluting of farming practices. The key is defining a transition from the status quo to the ideal where allocations are made on the basis of best practice. So that’s a tradeable market for rights. So grandparenting of rights in perpetuity would not be a goer, but a defined and reasonable pathway will be necessary.
The other problem with grandparenting is that it gives a terrible incentive – valuable rights to pollute are handed to those who do it most. This means that those land users who improve farming practices or have chosen to use less intensive farming methods are penalised.
Was this helpful?